Excerpted from "Cloning advance using stem cells from human adult reopens
ethical questions,"
Washington Post, April 17, 2014 - Scientists have grown
stem cells from adults using cloning techniques for the first time — bringing
them closer to developing patient-specific lines of cells that can be used to
treat a whole host of ailments, from heart disease to blindness. The research,
described in Thursday’s online edition of the journal
Cell Stem Cell,
is a controversial advance likely to reopen the debate over the ethics of human
cloning.
The scientists’ technique was similar to the one used in the first clone of a
mammal, Dolly the sheep, which was created in 1996. They “reprogrammed” an egg
cell by removing its DNA and replaced it with that of an adult donor. Scientists
then zapped the cell with electricity, which made it divide and multiply. The
resulting cells were identical in DNA to the donor.
Paul Knoepfler, an associate professor at the University of California at
Davis who studies stem cells, called the new research “exciting, important and
technically convincing.”
“In theory you could use those stem cells to produce almost any kind of cell
and give it back to a person as a therapy,” he said.
While the research published Thursday involves cells that are technically an
early stage embryo, the intention is not to try to grow them into a fully formed
human. However, the techniques in theory could be a first step toward creating a
baby with the same genetic makeup as a donor.
Shoukhrat Mitalipov, director of the Center for Embryonic Cell and Gene
Therapy at Oregon Health & Science University, developed the method that
Chung’s group built upon. He emphasized that the work involves eggs that have
not been fertilized.
“There will always be opposition to embryonic research, but the potential
benefits are huge,” Mitalipov said.
Seventeen years ago, news about Dolly’s birth led to impassioned calls for a
ban on human cloning for the purpose of producing a baby who is a genetic copy
of someone else. Several countries took measures to limit or outlaw such work.
But in the United States, the issue became entangled in the politics of
abortion, and Congress became deadlocked. Some lawmakers called for a ban on
reproductive human cloning, but others refused to support such legislation
unless it included a ban on human cloning whether it was for the purposes of
reproduction or for the development of new therapies. At least 15 states have
laws addressing human cloning.
CMDA Member and Senior Fellow for Life Sciences at
Family Research Council David Prentice, PhD: – “The language continues
to be deceptive. Growing ‘stem cells from adults using cloning techniques’
sounds innocent, as if they had taken one heart cell and multiplied it in a
dish. Making a ‘reprogrammed’ egg cell, getting it to divide, producing cells
‘identical in DNA to the donor.’ And the requisite ‘exciting’ and ‘new
therapies.’
“But the reality is that a new human being was produced by the cloning
technique (somatic cell nuclear transfer.) This news story notes that it is
‘technically an early stage embryo,’ but goes on to minimize the humanity of
this young being, created asexually in the lab, and instead point toward the
theoretical possibilities if the embryo is instead used as raw materials,
destroyed for embryonic stem cells that have in reality produced not a single
therapy.
“But there is no technicality--this is really an embryo, the youngest stage
of human life, just as Dolly the sheep started as a cloned sheep embryo. And
while any therapies are conjectural, the reality is the increased likelihood of
cloned human children from this scientific advance. In other stories, the
cloners themselves admit that the clones they created could develop and be born
if implanted in surrogate wombs. It all starts with creation of the new, cloned
embryo, an embryo that could then be used for cell stock or transferred to a
womb.
“Further, left unsaid is an additional scientific abuse inherent in cloning
technology—exploitation of women. Cloning relies on eggs to make the new, living
clones, no matter their intended final use. Lots and lots of eggs. The current
experiment used seven young women as egg donors (a procedure known to risk their
health), collecting a total of 126 eggs for experiments, but resulting in only
two cell lines. Egg donors were ‘financially reimbursed,’ an economic incentive
that can prey especially on poor young women. An industry that induces women to
exchange their eggs and risk their health is exploitive and should not be
countenanced.
“It’s time there was an outcry to prohibit manufacture and trafficking of any
cloned humans.”
Resources
Understanding the Ethics and Opportunity of Scientific
Research - Dr. David Prentice
CMDA
Resources on Stem Cell Research
Action
Use our Freedom2Care quick and easy
message system to alert your Representative about human
cloning and the need to support a legislative ban,
HR 2164.