Excerpted from "
Does Contraception Really Reduce the Abortion Rate?,"
commentary by Michael J. New,
National Review Online, June 17, 2014 -
Last week, the Guttmacher Institute released an
analysis of the recent decline in the incidence of abortion.
Overall, the abortion rate declined by an impressive 13 percent between 2008 and
2011 and reached its lowest level since 1973. This Guttmacher analysis joins a
chorus of pundits — including
Andrew Sullivan — who were quick to credit contraception for
this decline in the abortion rate. And like most Guttmacher studies, this
analysis is quick to downplay pro-life laws and other pro-life efforts.
The author makes a fair point that the abortion decline was fairly consistent
throughout the country and was not concentrated in states that were active in
passing pro-life laws. He correctly points out the sharp increase in state-level
pro-life laws took place after the abortion decline already happened. However,
the study presents a false dichotomy between either crediting legislation or
crediting contraceptives for the falling abortion numbers. Indeed, it neglects
other factors such as public opinion. In 2009, for the very first time, Gallup
reported that a majority of Americans described themselves as “pro-life.”
A longer term analysis of abortion trends reveals insights which weaken
Guttmacher’s case. Last month, the Charlotte Lozier Institute released a
study by Susan Wills analyzing the U.S. abortion decline from
1990 to 2010. The key finding is that the abortion decline has not been uniform
among age groups. The declines have been the greatest in both absolute and
percentage terms among teens and women in their early 20s. This is important for
two reasons. First, Long Acting Reversible Contraceptives (LARCs), which are
touted by Guttmacher, tend to be unpopular with this subset of women. Second,
there is a growing body of data showing declines in teen sexual activity since
the early 1990s. As such, contraceptive use may be playing less of a role in the
long-term abortion decline than the Guttmacher analysis would indicate.
Additional analysis further weakens Guttmacher’s argument. According to its
own statistics, the number of abortions has fallen by roughly 34 percent since
1990 and the abortion rate has fallen by 38 percent since that time. It is true
that contraception use has increased since the early 1990s, but it’s also true
that contraception use has been rising steadily since the early 1960s, and
obviously predates the abortion decline by a significant number of years. More
importantly, even though contraceptive use has gone up, the fertility rate and
unintended pregnancy rate have both actually increased slightly since the
mid-1990s. All in all, pro-life efforts to change the hearts and minds of women
facing crisis pregnancies might be more effective than commonly realized.
CMDA Executive Vice President Gene Rudd, MD – “When
I recently asked an accountant for a financial report, her response was,
“What do you want the numbers to be?” I had heard this as a joke, but
she seemed serious. When I told her I wanted the numbers to be accurate, she
explained that she could make a variety of assumptions and chose different
methodologies that would produce somewhat different results. If I had a
preference for how the numbers should look, she would make decisions that would
influence the numbers in that direction. To me it sounded like cooking the
books; essentially asking what I wanted 2 + 2 to equal.
“And it is not only in accounting. The medical and scientific literature are
replete with similar biases and influences that determine outcome, intentional
or not. A survey published in the journal
Naturei revealed
the magnitude of the problem, from poor record keeping (27 percent) to outright
fraud. And these were the researchers themselves admitting wrongdoing! Actual
misbehavior may be higher.
“We should be wary that those with social or political agendas will cook the
books, reporting data the way that serves their purpose. What do you think the
Guttmacher Institute (founded and funded by Planned Parenthood) wants the
numbers to be?”
Resources
CMDA Resources on
Abortion
iMartinson BC, Anderson MS, de Vries R. Scientists behaving badly,
Nature 435/9, June 2005.